A confession: I’ve had this book on my ‘to read’ pile for a few years now, and I really wish I had read it sooner. Deep Church, as the subtitle suggests, attempts to find “A Third Way Beyond Emerging and Traditional”.
Depending on the circles you travel in, you may not know what the author means by “Emerging” or “Traditional”. Within the realm of evangelicalism, a movement began some 20 years ago that became known as the Emerging (or Emergent) Church. It isn’t a denomination and doesn’t have formal leadership (though there are informal leaders). And, as this book, highlights, there is no theological or liturgical unity around the movement. Some Emerging churches look like mainline liberalism in a new suit, while others look like typical evangelical congregations, but with candles and corporate prayers of confession.
What Belcher looks for is a “third way”, something that finds balance between traditional evangelical Christianity and this somewhat numinous Emerging movement. What he comes up with is “Deep Church”, as he calls it, the model for ministry that he uses in his own congregation, Redeemer Presbyterian Church (PCA) in Newport Beach, California.
The big learning for me from this book was about the value of community. I’ve been thinking a lot about community in the church in recent years, and this has helped me even more to pinpoint what needs to happen if the church is to be effective with the millennial generation. Belcher writes about his congregation’s four core commitments: gospel, community, mission and shalom (the latter defined as making or transforming culture, in a Kuyperian sense).
I found the stories he told reinforced the points he was making from his research and his interviews with key players in the Emergent-Traditional debate, and the book’s 207 pages (plus copious endnotes) read fairly quickly. I wish I had read this sooner.
Deep Church: A Third Way Beyond Emerging and Traditional by Jim Belcher (foreword by Richard J. Mouw), published in 2009 by InterVarsity Press. ISBN 978-0-8308-3716-8.